General Motors is trying to win back shoppers who have drifted toward online used car sellers such as Carvana and CarMax. Its answer is CarBravo, an online portal where Chevrolet, Buick and GMC dealers list certified used vehicles, including cars made by other automakers. About 1,615 of GM's 3,700 dealers are enrolled, according to the company. Cadillac runs its own program.

The strategy makes sense for GM. New vehicle sales are more profitable for automakers, and a trade-in sent to a wholesale auction brings in far less revenue than a sale to a new customer, as John Fitzpatrick, senior manager of the CarBravo program, acknowledged. GM plans about 250,000 CarBravo sales in 2026, and Fitzpatrick does not expect even half to become new car sales. The company says about 38% of used shoppers end up buying new, a figure GM has reported but that the report does not independently verify.

The bigger question is what the customer gains. Certification, inspection and warranties are real benefits, and access to GM's service network is a legitimate selling point. The report also notes that about 70% of buyers gained through the program had never visited the dealership they bought from, which suggests the program is reaching people who might otherwise have shopped elsewhere.

But the monthly payment is where shoppers need to be careful. Industry analysts quoted in the report say buyers focus on payments rather than sticker prices, and Ivan Feinseth of Tigress Financial Partners noted that new cars can carry 5- or 6-year loans, while older used cars often mean shorter terms. Edmunds reported that loans of 84 months reached a record share, more than 1 in 4, in the third quarter. A longer loan can make a new truck look affordable while raising the total cost.

Dealers, meanwhile, gain from the relationship. Service visits often account for about half of dealership profits, according to the report, and Honda's Lance Woelfer said certified buyers return for service at a rate about 18% higher than buyers of non-certified used cars. Shoppers should judge the deal on total price, interest and warranty terms, not on how little a payment seems. Automakers should be clear about how often a used-car search turns into a new-car sale. Buyers deserve that transparency before they sign.