Frequent flyer miles were supposed to be the consolation prize for loyal travelers, a way to turn years of spending into a free seat home for the holidays. This Thanksgiving, that promise looks thinner than ever. According to data from Seats.aero, a miles and points redemption search site cited in the report, tickets bought with miles for flights between large U.S. airports over the Thanksgiving travel period will cost 32% more than last year's holiday.
The deeper problem is how the pricing works. Airlines have largely abandoned static mileage redemption charts in favor of dynamic pricing, in which the number of miles required rises and falls with demand, route and other factors. A chart let travelers plan a trip and know what it would cost. Dynamic pricing makes budgeting for an award ticket a guessing game, and the house wins most of the guesses. The report notes that the most expensive routes include a nonstop from New York to Houston, a short-haul trip that hardly fits the image of a rare, long-distance reward.
Airlines will point to fuel. The report says jet fuel prices have surged since the U.S. and Israel attacked Iran on Feb. 28, and that this has eaten into airline profits, with carriers seeking to pass costs along to consumers as much as possible. That explanation is plausible, but it does not justify the outcome for loyalty members. Miles are not cash. Members earn them through years of flying and credit card spending, and when the redemption price climbs, the value of that accumulated balance quietly shrinks. Even the cheapest award routes in the report, such as Tulsa, Oklahoma, to Dallas Fort Worth International Airport, cost more than they did last year.
The report also says airline executives last month described demand as strong. If demand is strong enough to justify higher prices, it is strong enough to justify keeping the program's terms transparent. Regulators and consumer advocates should press carriers to publish clearer redemption rules and to limit how quickly award prices can change for flights already on sale.
Travelers can respond practically. Check award prices before assuming miles are the cheaper option, compare them with cash fares, and book early when the price is known. But the larger responsibility lies with the airlines, which have turned a loyalty program into a moving target.