Shoppers are rejecting cheap synthetic clothing and paying closer attention to fabric content, according to a CNBC Business report.
The report says the makeup of apparel imported into the U.S. has shifted. In 2010, about 60% of clothing was predominantly cotton. Now that share is around 45%, while predominantly synthetic fabrics such as polyester and nylon make up the majority of imports.
Apparel prices generally fell in the two decades before the pandemic, according to the consumer price index. Since 2020, they have risen to record highs.
AlixPartners' 2026 Consumer Sentiment Index, which surveyed more than 9,000 shoppers, found that consumers are scrutinizing labels more closely and rejecting cheap materials sold at a premium. Sonia Lapinsky, head of fashion at AlixPartners, said that if a retailer passes off a non-natural material as something else, consumers "are really becoming very low on" that brand.
U.S. Bancorp BTIG consumer analyst Janine Stichter said the industry has reached a turning point. "We got to a point where the pendulum just swung too far in that direction. And we've actually begun to see a reversal," she said. She added that quality "matters a lot more" over the last three or four years than it did in the prior decade or two.
Quality often costs more. Data from the U.S. Commerce Department's Office of Textiles and Apparel show the average unit price of imported apparel from January through August was $2.64 per square meter for predominantly synthetic garments and $3.67 for largely cotton items. Compared with 2010, synthetic apparel import costs rose about 11%, while cotton apparel costs rose 21%.
Bernstein Research senior retail analyst Aneesha Sherman said retailers serving value-sensitive customers may cut quality, negotiate with suppliers or absorb costs. Sherman also said the athleisure boom is a primary factor in the shift toward polyester. From 2015 to 2025, sports apparel grew at a 4.9% rate in the U.S., compared with 2.6% for all apparel and footwear, according to Euromonitor data.
Backlash against synthetic materials is growing. The report says Gen Z has repurposed the word "polyester" as an insult meaning low-quality or fake. Concerns about human health and the environment are also rising, as more research indicates microplastics can leach from polyester clothing when washed.
Stichter said post-pandemic demand, tariffs and the Iran war raised costs for businesses and consumers. Oil prices have risen sharply since the Iran war began, and many synthetic fibers are petroleum-based. Stichter said companies moved their supply chains and sometimes used less expensive fabrics to cut costs.
Ralph Lauren is cited as a company benefiting from this shift. Its stock is up around 85% over the past two years, according to the report. Around 90% of its apparel is primarily made of cotton, leather, wool, viscose, cashmere or silk, according to its 2026 sustainability report.