Alphabet lost just over $500bn (£374bn) in value on Thursday, and the reason is worth sitting with. Its quarterly results were not bad on the surface. Total revenue grew 25% to $127.6bn, and Google Cloud revenue grew 103% to almost $31bn. Those are the numbers a company shows when it wants investors to believe the future is bright. Investors looked past them and sold, because the figures underneath told a harder story.
Profits fell 25% during the quarter. Alphabet also posted negative free cash flow in excess of $9bn, its second such result in its history as a public company, and almost twice the cash loss it showed three months earlier. As the report explains, that means the company is now spending more than it brings in, and that new spending is almost entirely dedicated to Google's AI investments. Free cash flow is the money left after running the business and funding its investments, so a negative figure is hard to dismiss as an accounting quirk.
The more troubling detail is where the pressure is landing. Google's search engine now defaults to AI summaries of a person's query, and according to the report, that reduced the number of advertisements the company could sell. Advertising next to search results is the vast majority of Alphabet's business. Tracy Woo, a principal analyst at Forrester, said the disappointing search results "highlights the challenge of funding massive AI investments while maintaining the strength of established businesses." That is the core problem in one sentence: the cash cow is being asked to fund a product that may weaken the cash cow.
Google's chief business officer, Phillip Schindler, said on Wednesday that he felt "very good about our trajectory" with an AI-focused search engine. Management confidence is not a financial result, and the market clearly decided it was not enough. The stock fell almost 13% on Thursday, its second lowest showing this year, and its total market value dropped from $3.97 trillion to $3.46 trillion in a single day.
Chief executive Sundar Pichai has backed the spending, and Microsoft and Amazon are also committing astronomical sums to the same race. Alphabet should keep building, but it should stop treating investor patience as unlimited. It needs to show, quarter by quarter, that AI is adding revenue and profit rather than only replacing the search ads that funded it. Until then, the market will keep asking the question Thursday's sell-off posed: what happens when the new business costs more than the old one earns?